Mapping Social Media: The Community vs. Broadcast Quadrant
Understanding how everyday people navigate and use social media platforms.
Social media apps tend to fall into two categories: community-driven apps and broadcast-oriented apps. For the average user, each app serves a different purpose, fosters different types of engagement, and shapes how they connect with each other, influencers, and brands.
Community-driven platforms bring real people together and encourage direct interaction. These connections can be between real-life friends, family, and neighbors (WhatsApp, Facebook, Nextdoor) or between people with shared interests (Discord, Reddit, Mastodon).
Like early social media (think MySpace, IRC, Usenet), these platforms prioritize group discussions and ongoing conversations. A Discord server, for example, is built around continuous, real-time interaction, while a WhatsApp group keeps a small set of users engaged in private conversations. Reddit fosters open discussions within niche communities, where users contribute rather than passively consume.
The relationships formed on community platforms tend to be stronger because engagement is more participatory. People are there to interact with one another, not just follow a creator or passively consume content. For brands and marketers, these platforms offer an opportunity to build deeper relationships—whether through private customer groups, brand communities, or direct engagement with fans.
Broadcast-oriented platforms are designed for scale. They are built around content creators and brands producing content for large audiences, often without authentic direct engagement. Platforms like TikTok and YouTube prioritize discovery, virality, and one-to-many interactions.
On these platforms, engagement exists in the form of likes, shares, and comments, but most interactions are between a creator and an audience rather than between users. While a brand might respond to comments on an Instagram post or a viral tweet, the engagement is often surface-level and transactional rather than part of an ongoing conversation.
For marketers, broadcast platforms are essential for brand awareness, campaign reach, and content distribution. The challenge is standing out in a crowded space and finding ways to turn passive viewers into active participants.
Strategies like interactive content, live Q&As, and personalized responses can help bridge the gap between broadcast and community-style engagement. And broadcast apps are recognizing the importance of community—YouTube has added moderated communities, and Instagram is experimenting with Discord-like chat.
Within both community and broadcast platforms, there’s another layer: whether they cater to a broad or niche audience.
Broad platforms attract mass audiences across a wide range of topics. Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook are used by billions of people with diverse interests.
Niche platforms serve specific communities. Twitch is built for gamers, Mastodon appeals to decentralized social media users, and Nextdoor is for hyperlocal networking.
Some platforms, like Reddit and LinkedIn, operate across both. LinkedIn is broadly used but has a professional focus, while Reddit has countless niche communities within its large user base.
Understanding whether a platform is broad or niche helps marketers determine where their target audience spends time and what kind of content will resonate. A highly specialized audience may engage more deeply in niche community spaces, while broad platforms offer the potential for scale and discovery.
People use community-driven platforms differently than broadcast platforms, and that impacts how brands should approach engagement.
And we know people want their favorite brands and organizations to foster community—76.6% of consumers wish their favorite brands had a community, and 67.4% feel more connected through community than through traditional social media.
Community platforms require ongoing participation. Marketers should focus on long-term engagement, fostering discussions, and creating spaces where people feel connected. Successful strategies include running exclusive membership groups, engaging directly with users, and co-creating content with the community.
Broadcast platforms are about visibility and scale. The key is delivering content that captures attention and drives action. This means optimizing for platform algorithms, leveraging trends, and ensuring content is engaging enough to prompt shares and comments.
Social media isn’t one-size-fits-all, and the best strategies combine both approaches. A brand might use TikTok for reach while using Discord to build deeper relationships with its most engaged customers. Knowing when to prioritize community over broadcast—and vice versa—helps ensure social efforts align with your organization's goals.
My favorite Substack 🙂↕️